Premium accounts
are only £9.99 - Upgrade now

Allstarz 8th thread!!

Viewing forum thread.
Back to Clan and League Chat.
Back to Forum List.

Pages: 19697
98
99100
linfield1886
linfield1886
Posts: 1,962
21:59 Thu 11 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
1 - reg
2 - arcade
3 - orig
linfield1886
linfield1886
Posts: 1,962
22:06 Thu 11 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
Good man

Hey guys - some feedback/comments on my last post would b good


cazorla's comments are valid.

Also ranks are meaningless.

Im happy to pick the best team as I see it and take the flak for upsetting ppl. Its just not what we have been about in the past or something I enjoy doing.

More than happy to give your idea a go though. Would be a good way to implement squad rotation. But I warn you now I wont be subbing in to play seb every game this season


I just think its worth a try, there will b lots of squad rotation unless we produce wonder results (and if we do, then we owe it to ourselves to keep the same team). The whole point is u wouldn't b subbing into play seb, whoever is top of the bench and has that game type selected wud b. Obviously my idea isn't flawless and some ppl will feel hard done by if they get a tough opponent but I think it wud b fun + provide a challenge + incentive. If u do get benched, so b it, u will get another go pretty quickly I reckon
horse10000
horse10000
Moderator
Posts: 792
22:12 Thu 11 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
Good man
Hey guys - some feedback/comments on my last post would b good

cazorla's comments are valid.
Also ranks are meaningless.
Im happy to pick the best team as I see it and take the flak for upsetting ppl. Its just not what we have been about in the past or something I enjoy doing.
More than happy to give your idea a go though. Would be a good way to implement squad rotation. But I warn you now I wont be subbing in to play seb every game this season

I just think its worth a try, there will b lots of squad rotation unless we produce wonder results (and if we do, then we owe it to ourselves to keep the same team). The whole point is u wouldn't b subbing into play seb, whoever is top of the bench and has that game type selected wud b. Obviously my idea isn't flawless and some ppl will feel hard done by if they get a tough opponent but I think it wud b fun + provide a challenge + incentive. If u do get benched, so b it, u will get another go pretty quickly I reckon

I think there are a few more flaws with this. Every player will go on the same loop, does a player who doesn't play his games and makes little effort to get them played deserve the same games/opportunities? If a player has won a few games in a row and has played them without needing chased, and then he plays seb does he deserve to be dropped, in my opinion he doesn't but others might disagree.
horse10000
horse10000
Moderator
Posts: 792
22:12 Thu 11 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
Preferences is still anything
thegreatone7
thegreatone7
Posts: 4,549
22:19 Thu 11 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
yeaaa thats true horse
Deleted User
(IP Logged)
23:00 Thu 11 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
Fair point horse.. I'll just keep hutch on the bench. He's the only one I had to chase last season

He can't work out how to use the forum. It's beyond his it skills
thegreatone7
thegreatone7
Posts: 4,549
23:06 Thu 11 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
well it is hard to work out uno lots of buttons to press
kilimanjaro
kilimanjaro
Posts: 5,209
23:25 Thu 11 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
1. slatty = 1st: power, 2nd: original, 3rd: Reg (Captain)
2. linfield1886 = arcade and regular + original if stuck (Vice Captain)
3. sarahh = regular and carom (Vice Captain)
4. doomslave = F1, Golf and table tennis
5. hutch1971 = regular and original
6. horse10000 = any type
7. deitch = reg and power (im guessing?)
9. naaaaaaaaath = carom arcade, regular and original
10. mylo = Original + others, but not carom
11. the_rider = carom , arcade , regular
12. roxbury_100 = carom
13. i_am_cazorla = carom + cluedo
14. kilimanjaro = original,regular,arcade,power , golf, football , cricket., rugby, scrabble and wiff waff..., rubbish at tennis tho
15. thegreatone7 = arcade

Please all confirm your favorite modes in order of preference (as I have done to mine above)
original,regular,arcade,power

My preferences highlighted


Evening all
linfield1886
linfield1886
Posts: 1,962
01:17 Fri 12 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
Good point horse but someone who makes no effort to play will likely get a default loss of 6-0 and wud b last choice on subs bench for next fixture ( or, if some1 is not making effort to get game played +not updating us then we sub them out to get game played + they wud go to bottom of subs bench)

Edited at 22:24 Thu 11/10/12 (BST)
Deleted User
(IP Logged)
01:26 Fri 12 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
I say just keep it simple - pick whoever'll play lol
sarahh
sarahh
Posts: 13,453
01:27 Fri 12 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
what bout if i win 4-2 in a clan game , next game i lose 6-0 to a top class player , would i lose my place and be on the bench ?
Deleted User
(IP Logged)
01:45 Fri 12 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
what bout if i win 4-2 in a clan game , next game i lose 6-0 to a top class player , would i lose my place and be on the bench ?


Agree Sarah , so basically we would prob get punished for losing a match vs the so called big guns ???

My 2 defeats last season came at the hands of Sean and sean_paul they are in top 2 or 3 ,so would I get ' benched' for this ????

And it's reg and orig and order
dgeneratio
dgeneratio
Moderator
Posts: 54,204
02:08 Fri 12 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
Hi! i see your signed up for the league



as you know clan registrations end at midnight tonight and any changes can be made on this thread until then (on this thread please quote the last list used)...

http://www.funkysnooker.com/thread/6487/clan-league-signups

even though the clan signups is over tonight from tonight/tomorrow 00:00 GMT you can still do changes to your team can you use the team changes thread for this (on this thread post who is in and who is out and not the full list)...

http://www.funkysnooker.com/thread/7014/clan-league-team-changes

New additions do not need an account age before the friendlies start, on Sunday then all future additions will need their account age to be 31 days to be eligible

We will be asking for teamlists tomorrow for the pre season friendlies for Sundays release as well so stay tuned



Thanks and welcome to Season 11

Edited at 23:13 Thu 11/10/12 (BST)
linfield1886
linfield1886
Posts: 1,962
07:58 Fri 12 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
I say just keep it simple - pick whoever'll play lol


The lights are on but nobody's home, eh?!

The whole point is we're all in the team to play!!! However there are more of us in team than spaces available.

There is no ideal scenario guys. I'm just trying to find a ccompromise that will see us try to maximise potential as last year we rotated and fielded several weakened teams. We can't just pick strongest team week in week out as others will get peeved.
linfield1886
linfield1886
Posts: 1,962
08:03 Fri 12 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
what bout if i win 4-2 in a clan game , next game i lose 6-0 to a top class player , would i lose my place and be on the bench ?


Yes.

Though you would have had 2 games in a row anyway so probably fair that someone else gets a go - I think I was left out of 2 out of 6 (- think) league games last season so if we are just going to randomly rotate you will miss games anyway.

I guess the msg is try not to lose! If u do, don't worry, you will b back in soon enough.
linfield1886
linfield1886
Posts: 1,962
08:11 Fri 12 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
Its good to get a bit of feedback guys - feedback can be positive too

If we can't agree to this (or another selection policy - get your thinking hats on!!) Then I'm now strongly of the opinion that we should field strongest team for every given fixture next season (we defo sold ourselves a bit short last season and need to kick on now) - bear in mind though that this would mean little rotation + if you aren't one of the stronger players, you wouldn't get too many games
Deleted User
(IP Logged)
10:33 Fri 12 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
I say just keep it simple - pick whoever'll play lol


The lights are on but nobody's home, eh?!

The whole point is we're all in the team to play!!! However there are more of us in team than spaces available.

There is no ideal scenario guys. I'm just trying to find a ccompromise that will see us try to maximise potential as last year we rotated and fielded several weakened teams. We can't just pick strongest team week in week out as others will get peeved.


? I'm just here for the free food!
linfield1886
linfield1886
Posts: 1,962
10:46 Fri 12 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
Lol
dgeneratio
dgeneratio
Moderator
Posts: 54,204
15:11 Fri 12 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
Preseason Friendlies are here please send 2 lists to dgeneratio or whocares8x8 preferably both by Sunday.

For those new to clans captains please send me...

2 players for Arcade
2 players for Regular
2 players for Original
2 players for Carom
1 player for Power

Players you can use can be found here: http://www.funkysnooker.com/thread/7014/clan-league-team-changes/72#678644

changes for teamsheet are still legal until Sunday

Lineups are as follows...

Allstarz vs Anger Management
Dollars & Cents vs Black Ballers
Predators vs Noobs
Total Domination vs Black Ops

Anger Management vs Predators
Dollars & Cents vs Noobs
Allstarz vs Total Domination
Black Ballers vs Black Ops

Thanks
Deleted User
(IP Logged)
16:11 Fri 12 Oct 12 (BST)  [Link]  
Hey lads.

My order is...

Original
Regular
Power
Arcade

NO Carom please. I think there are enough specialists in here and I am definately not one of them.

In regard to linnie's idea. I think its a lot of calculating and preparation necessary to find this order every fixture. While vice captaining Vikings we always found a team without this. As soon somebody felt treated unfair it was solved in the usual manner of sending pm's to the captains and a solution was found.
For me there is no need to develop a system like this.
Pages: 19697
98
99100
Unable to post
Reason:You must log in before you can post

Allstarz 8th thread!!

Back to Top of this Page
Back to Clan and League Chat.
Back to Forum List.